Decision draws nigh in longtime debate for Jersey Shore Area School District buildings
Trending
JERSEY SHORE -- The impassioned speeches for and against school closure have been given at almost every meeting in the last five months. Now comes the tough job the Jersey Shore Area School Board has: making a decision about the future of the district's elementary schools.
At a board meeting earlier this month, Mary Thomas, board president, said that a decision would be made within 30 days.
What scenario presented will be chosen? That is the question on the minds of district residents.
One option is Scenario A -- Salladasburg Elementary School closes. All students in kindergarten through third grade there move to Jersey Shore Elementary and all students in grades four and five move to Avis Elementary.
In a survey the district conducted earlier in the school year, the majority of respondents felt that smaller elementary buildings, which would be Salladasburg and Avis, should remain open. Judging from public comments at board meetings, parents in the Salladasburg area, whose children would be most affected by the closing of the elementary school, are most adamant about keeping the school open. They like the smaller class sizes, and some have threatened to move their children to a charter school if the closure option is chosen.
Although this discussion of school closure began at the beginning of the current school year, the history of this issue goes back years, even to 2017.
The district had closed Nippenose Valley Elementary in 2014, in a cost-saving measure -- although many people contend that the money that was supposed to be saved by the closure never materialized.
Then in 2017, the district revisited the issue of closing the smaller elementary schools. The issue would resurface periodically, but there was never any vote by board members to follow through with closing one or more of the outlying elementary schools.
At times it seems that there is a discrepancy among the facts that those for and against closure present. One side says that schools should stay open in case the enrollment, which has been trending downward, starts to increase.
"I think there isn't a discrepancy in the data that we have internally, that we are given," said Dr. Brian Ulmer, district superintendent.
"What the concern ... is -- is it going to continue to decline, or is it going to go up?" he said. "I think those are the comments that we hear -- concern that we would not have a building and then need a building."
One of the problems is determining where enrollment is decreasing.
"We've gotten into arguments about where it's decreasing," Ulmer said. "Is it this level of the district versus this level? And that's where some of the arguments come from. The overall number is not the same as it was before, and there we get into arguments over, 'Well, the numbers are higher or lower here,' or 'Why is it higher or lower here,'" he said.
Jersey Shore Elementary, located in the borough of Jersey Shore, is the largest elementary school in the district, with an enrollment well over 500. Avis is the smallest, and Salladasburg is slightly larger than Avis.
Keeping class sizes lower is one of the main arguments parents give for keeping the smaller schools open.
Transportation is another issue, and at the last board meeting, the cost of transporting students in all of the three scenarios was estimated.
For A, with closing Salladasburg, transportation cost would increase $72,700.
With Scenario B, Jersey Shore Elementary would house all students in grades three to five and Avis and Salladasburg would each have half of the students in grades K-2. The increase in transportation costs would be $160,505.
In the survey conducted by the district administration, although none of the scenarios had been introduced at that point, of the 825 people who responded, over half, 572, were opposed to realigning the elementary buildings so that all the students in the same grade were together in a building to balance out the class sizes.
Scenario C would see all three elementary buildings remain K-5, but students would be shifted to Avis and Salladasburg in order to equalize class sizes. Transportation costs would increase $100,788.
Each of the scenarios also has the potential for teacher position reductions, which could offset the increase in transportation costs.
Plan C has received some support from parents, if comments at board meetings are indicative of the mood in the district.
Some people at the meetings have contended that there are empty classrooms at Salladasburg, but Ulmer disputed that.
"I wouldn't say there's really any empty classrooms," he said.
"The issue is for example in some grades there may be 32 kids. So, we have 32 kids in a grade level. We can't have them in one classroom. That means we have two classes of 16 kids, so there's room for more kids without adding a teacher," he explained.
The survey did not include questions about the demographics of the people participating, so it is not apparent if they were younger or older residents of the district or what area of the district they lived -- Salladasburg, Avis or Jersey Shore Borough.
Younger commenters at meetings seem to focus on class size and students, while older residents are concerned about rising tax costs. Some of those people responding to the survey said that they would not be opposed to an increase in taxes in order to upgrade schools.
After so many years of kicking this issue around, Ulmer hopes that this will be the end of the discussion.
At the end of the last board meeting, he issued a statement about the need to move on.
"This board will make a decision. Even if the decision is to remain status quo, that is a decision," he said.
"The board has spent hours in public meetings discussing, listening, asking questions, and looking at data. They will make an informed decision. There will be someone, perhaps multiple people, that will believe that they have lost. Regardless of when the vote occurs, students will come to school the next day. I will make sure that they come into the best learning environment possible in whatever situation the district is in. Our amazing staff will do their job and the students will still learn," he said.
I have been asked numerous times what I want. What I want is for this school district, its staff, and its students to be able to move on. To be able to learn, to achieve, and to move forward without this cloud hanging over their head for years to come. It is the job of the superintendent to make a recommendation to the board. Tonight, my recommendation is that no matter what is decided, the board support it and forge a path forward. This community must come to terms with the fact that the path forward has got to be one that everyone is on. Whether you feel like you have won or lost, the students of this school district deserve the support of everyone," Ulmer said.
But, what will happen financially to the district which has seen its fund balance going down in order to balance the budgets if nothing changes?
"I don't believe that it will have an immediate impact on the 2023-24 budget, but what I hear from the board is (about) making long-term decisions," Ulmer said.
"If you go back to the beginning of this conversation in August, one of the concerns that brought this up is the long-term outlook of the district. It really started from a capital projects conversation. We want to make sure that we maintain our buildings and maintain our facilities and we upkeep on all those things and make sure that our programs are viable for kids," he said.
That was when the conversation began, he said, with board members voicing, "if every year our budget is this tight how do we long-range plan."