Trending
Lycoming County commissioners claim mistakes resulting in the loss of thousands of dollars and unsuccessful attempts to correct issues left them with little choice but to transfer several employees out of the Controllers office.
The vote by each of the commissioners as members of the county salary board is not occurring without a fight from Controller Krista Rogers who has accused them of violating county code.
In a recent interview with the Sun-Gazette, commissioners cited errors with payroll, billing and other problems in the Controller's office.
They claim they tried to work with Rogers to remedy matters before each voting recently to transfer the four employees to the office of budget and finance.
Rogers, the other member of the salary board, voted no, and has maintained the four will remain under her supervision.
"It's a multitude of mistakes," Commissioner Tony Mussare said. "She has cost this county thousands of dollars."
Mussare and his two colleagues could not put anything near an exact figure on how much money was lost.
Rogers has not disputed there have been mistakes. She does, however, take issue with how commissioners have dealt with her office in recent years.
"The employees they took out of my office are the same four they gave me four years ago. I had fought for them for 16 years," she said. "The controller is the watchdog. The only way I can check on anything is for money that goes out."
Mirabito said commissioners agreed upon her request at that time to move the four people into her office.
"We did what she asked us to do," he said.
He disputed that the commissioners are engaged in any kind of power grab to control her.
"If it was a power grab, we would not have done this."
Commissioners, she said, have no more right to take over the functions of her department than they do other departments.
Mirabito cited a memorandum of understanding of two years given to commissioners by Rogers outlining her duties and expectations of her office.
Rogers agreed she issued such a document but neither she nor the commissioners ever signed off on it.
In March, another memorandum of understanding was issued by the commissioners, this one including plans to transfer the four employees out of her office.
She said she was summoned to the offices of commissioners April 9 and told the move was going to be made.
"They say they want to work with me but it's only on their terms," she said.
She added that if she is being obstructive, as she has been accused, it's only because she is following the law.
Rogers has cited a section of the county code that she feels backs her claims that the commissioners are over-stepping their authority.
She has also claimed that the commissioners' move risks the payment of bills, including payroll, and filing a financial report. In addition, she claimed, commissioners are "eliminating the controller's office as the lawful check-and-balance of county expenditures."
Rogers noted that in 2020 her office put out a Comprehensive Annual Financial Report "during COVID, while being blocked in communication, training and information gathering by the commissioners' fiscal services director, who has since retired."
Beth Johnston, who served in that position, took issue with that accusation.
In an email to the Sun-Gazette, she wrote: "The Controller office is most definitely the problem. For the record, communication and training was never 'blocked' by anyone in Budget and Finance. Truth is the Controller would not allow 'her newly transferred staff' to ask for assistance from those that had the years of experience and the know-how. Government accounting is a specialized field. The Controller had no knowledge of how to train the individuals she took under her wing."
Commissioners cited several examples of problems or errors related to the Controller's Office.
In 2020, 39 county employees were either underpaid or overpaid as a result the office's errors, according to commissioners.
Mussare noted that payroll is a complicated process, involving both active and former employees.
Commissioners have claimed the transfer of the employees was to have them properly trained to carry out necessary functions of the Controller's office.
""The reason we transferred the employees is because they can't serve two masters," Commissioner Rick Mirabito said. "Our goal is to get the people trained. Our job is to protect the taxpayers."
Commissioner Scott Metzger noted that just recently a part-time employee received a check in error for about $49,000.
He noted that Rogers admitted the mistake and it was rectified.
"That is one example," he said. "The office personnel are not trained."
Another mistake, he noted, involved a line of credit with Children & Youth not paid in a timely fashion resulting in interest of several thousand dollars being accrued.
Metzger also cited employee turnover in the Controller's office.
Rogers said she simply didn't buy the notion that the employees will be better trained in the budget and finance department, be it in accounting, billing, payroll or other functions.
She said her office has taken corrective action for errors made in her office.
"Errors happened even before I took over (as controller)," she said.
She noted the recent check mistake was taken care of quickly after it was discovered.
"For the line of credit, that was not a timeliness error on my part," Rogers said. "We communicate throughout the county when we are closing the system at year end for processing and that all bills need to be in by a particular date to be processed in time before the system closes. The communication had been sent out that the system would be closed and year-end processing was already started when we were contacted that the bill they are referring to needed to be paid. I informed them that the year-end process had already started and there was no way to stop the process to cut an individual check. This is not a new concept or process that started once I took over, it is part of the financial system processing of year-end that has always been done, including for years previously by Fiscal Services."
"We have tried to work with her," Metzger said. "We have to go in a different direction. If these people get trained, we can send them back."
Metzger said it is his responsibility as a commissioner to ensure mistakes don't continue to happen.
"For two years we have tried to remedy this," Mirabito said. "We do have an obligation to the taxpayers of the county."
Rogers insisted that commissioners did not have to take the action they did.
She said she does not know at this point if she will pursue legal action.
Metzger said commissioners have not denied her access to anything.
"We have advised fiscal services to help her," he said. "The bottom line is we want her to succeed, and need to right the ship. We can't set up people for failure in her department. It has not been working for two years."
Mussare noted that county code requires commissioners to be the responsible manager and administrators of the fiscal affairs of the county.
"If we let things go, that is our responsibility," he said.
Metzger said he feels the commissioners are on solid legal footing with regard to the matter.