Breaking News
News

Jersey Shore man charged in off-duty police officer death

By Philip A. Holmes 3 min read

WATERVILLE -- A second arrest has been made in the strangulation death of 44-year-old off-duty Middlesex Township police officer Michael McGeehan, who was slain last summer during a family reunion in a cabin in the 7100 block of Dam Run Road in Cummings Township, according to Lycoming Regional police.

Michael James Huling, 56, of 624 Middle Road in Limestone Township, turned himself in Wednesday to face charges of involuntary manslaughter, recklessly endangering another person and hindering apprehension for his alleged involvement in causing McGeehan's death on July 11, police said.

Already arrested in the case was Paden Edward Frey, 25, of 6793 Pleasant Valley Road, Cogan Station, who has been jailed in the Lycoming County Prison on no bail since his arrest on Oct. 7. He is charged with murder of the third degree, strangulation, involuntary manslaughter and recklessly endangering another person. Frey is a cousin to McGeehan's wife, Nicole, who was in the cabin with other family members, including the couple's children, police said.

In court papers it was alleged that Huling "was reckless and negligent as he held down McGeehan while McGeehan was being strangled (allegedly by Frey)." Witnesses reported that McGeehan, who was president of his graduating class at the Harrisburg Area Community College's Municipal Police Academy and a 12-year veteran of the Middlesex Township Police Department in Cumberland County, "was extremely intoxicated," and those present were "trying to keep him safe by holding him down," it was stated in an affidavit.

Investigators allege that Frey "held his forearm against McGeehan's middle neck area until McGeehan passed out," the affidavit stated. During the confrontation, which lasted about 10 minutes, McGeehan "was trying to fight and was struggling to breathe," according to one witness. Frey told investigators that he and Huling had been "fighting with McGeehan, trying to get him to sleep. Frey stated that eventually they got McGeehan to lie down on the porch, where he fell asleep."

Huling, who is a distant relative to McGeehan's wife, told police that he "didn't do a whole lot and was just sitting back, but talking," the affidavit stated. However, police allege that Huling "failed to disclose to police that he had held down McGeehan while Frey applied pressure to McGeehan's neck until he lost consciousness," police alleged in the court document.

An autopsy revealed that McGeehan died of "manual strangulation," but there were other "contributing factors to the cause of death, including blunt force injuries to his head and extremities as well as acute and chronic alcohol abuse," the affidavit stated.

Following his arraignment before District Judge Denise Dieter, Huling was released on $100,000 bail. The preliminary hearing for both Frey and Huling is scheduled for Dec. 23.

Starting at /week.