Proposed data center scrutinized at public hearing
Trending
Although public comment on the proposed amendment to Lycoming County's zoning ordinance pertaining to data centers was light at the hearing held by the county commissioners this week, there were a few suggestions on how to tweak the document which governs data center
principal uses and data center accessory uses in the 19 municipalities under the county's zoning.
Brown, Bastress, Cascade. Cogan House, Gamble, Jackson, Jordan, Lewis, Limestone, McHenry, McIntyre, McNett, Mifflin, Moreland, Penn, Pine, Plunketts Creek and Porter Townships and Salladasburg Borough are the 19 municipalities that partner with the county.
Most of the comments during the public comment section of the hearing came from a resident of Muncy Township, which is not governed by the county's zoning, but rather makes their own planning and zoning decisions. The township is currently seeking to pass their own curative amendment for data center.
Earlier this year, the county had declared their zoning ordinance invalid because it did not address data centers, which Jenny Picciano, director of the county's planning and community development department, said was actually unheard of at the time the last amendment to the zoning ordinance was written.
"Through this amendment we are now trying to propose and establish clear standards for how and when these facilities will be used," Picciano said.
She noted that the amendment only applies to the municipalities in the county zoning partnership.
"If you are from a municipality that is not in that, I would encourage you to talk to your own elected officials who manage and operate your zoning ordinance to have this discussion," she said.
Picciano explained that the amendment was developed by ENTECH Professional Services PC, who were contracted by the county.
"As part of this, we did a lot of research into what other communities were doing," Picciano said.
"This was also reviewed by our planning commission solicitor and we also retained secondary legal counsel from an outside legal firm because it is such an important issue in our community," she said.
Picciano explained that the amendment establishes clear guidelines, definitions, and performance standards for the development and operations of principal data centers, which is the main data center and the accessory data center uses for the municipality partners. This would include things like generators and backup power.
She emphasized that included in the amendment is an extensive definition section about what constitutes a principal data center and data center accessories.
"Under our proposed ordinance, it would add data center principal uses and data center accessory uses to the zoning ordinance as specifically regulated industrial uses. So not agriculture, not residential, but specifically industrial uses relegated to the industrial zoning districts...The proposed ordinance would also establish supplemental standards for infrastructure, water, sewer, cooling, power, noise, emergency response, backup power systems, backup power generation, equipment recycling, electronic waste, decommissioning, among other standards," Picciano said.
"So together and collectively, these proposed regulations are intended to provide tools to evaluate potential impacts of data centers in these uses, and to protect nearby residents and sensitive areas, conserve our natural resources, and address infrastructure and public safety concerns," she said.
Other requirements outlined in the proposed amendment include setback and separation requirements from residential areas and sensitive receptors, which are things like schools and churches.
"We include noise and vibration standards that include pre-construction noise studies, noise model, and violation of motion. We require screening and fencing, emergency response planning, industrial-scale battery storage information, industrial-scale power generation standards, operational water meetings, water metering and reporting. We do require extensive coordination with the local water authorities if they are proposing to use public water, and financial security required," she said.
She pointed out that those requirements are clearly outlined in the ordinance and all data center development proposals must meet them before they are sent to the zoning board for approval.
Picciano said that the proposed ordinance does not guarantee approval of any future development.
"At this time, the county. I just want to state that we have not received any applications or development proposals for data centers or similar uses in the 19 municipalities that are under county jurisdiction," she said.
Loyalsock Township resident Jerry Walls, the former director at the planning department said that he feels the proposed ordinance has "a lot of good content, a lot of good standards," which "address the range of what's involved in a data center, including not just the setbacks for property lines and the general zoning categories in which they might be allowed, but also a lot of semi-emergency factors."
Although his township is not one of the county's partner municipalities, Walls said that he had compiled notes on the proposed ordinance that he said could be blended into a letter of comment.
"I think it's important for the county to go ahead and move ahead because these data centers and all the ancillary facilities that support them are certainly the wave of the near future," Walls said.
Steve Brady, of Gamble Township, which is one of the municipalities under the county's zoning, asked about the special exception process for permitting.
"I appreciate the fact that...if it’s going to have a data center, it’s going to have to go through a special exception, which tells me it’s going to have to go through a zoning hearing board. So, is there a chance that you could explain...what the special exception is compared to permitted or compared to variance," Brady said.
Heather George, of the county's planning department explained that "this particular use does go through the zoning hearing board. It’s a special exception use. It’s an approval by the zoning hearing board. They can set those conditions, specific conditions to that approval at any time. A variance would be any deviation from the ordinance as it is, any standards that the use is not met or the standards are not met with the variance. A use permitted by right is where a zoning officer is allowed to make that determination on that application, but this specific use is for special exception use by the zoning hearing board."
The special exception application would be submitted to be heard by the zoning hearing board which would be a public hearing.
Brady had also asked why there was no mention in the amendment about the power transmission lines used to supply electricity to a data center. Picciano told him that was determined through PPL and not the county.
Ariana Moore, of Williamsport, which is not under the aegis of Lycoming County Planning, said that she felt the ordinance was a "meaningful starting point," but advocated for making it stronger.
"I would ask that we actually make this amendment slightly stronger...to protect not only our rural communities, our private wells, agricultural land and all of our emergency services that may, in fact have to address anything that if it were to happen at a building site or after the data center is constructed," Moore said.
Referring to emergency services, Moore stated that "it would be great to understand who will pay for specialized training, equipment and response capacity that these facilities may require, specifically around volunteer fire departments and potential EMS providers and then compliance and enforcement."
"I would like to know how the county will verify compliance after construction," Moore said.
"It would be informative as well as helpful for defined corrective actions and consequences when standards are violated...let's build the Cadillac. Why not make these so that we have an amendment that actually serves residents of the entire county and protects them," she said.
The county will now consider all public comments received and a final vote will occur in December.