Trending
The James V. Brown Library deserves its accolades as Pennyslvania's Library of the Year.
"We are grateful to receive recognition from the Pennsylvania Library Association for overcoming a difficult censorship challenge and for all of the support we received from the community families that need diverse resource," Barbara S. McGary, the executive director of the library, told the Sun-Gazette in late October.
As a news release from the state Library Association noted, James V. Brown Library is "an inspiration to all libraries" for how it resisted pressure from Lycoming County Commissioners -- who control a significant portion of the library's funding stream -- to remove a display of age-appropriate books from the the children's library in observance of Pride Month.
"The James V. Brown Library provides a welcoming environment for every member of its community," the state association said, and part of providing that welcoming environment is allowing a voice from marginalized communities within our wider community.
The James V. Brown Library's stand would be commendable even if attempts to silence the often marginalized were extremely rare. But they are not.
In Virginia, as the 2021 governor's race approached its end, successful Republican nominee Glenn Youngkin chose to produce a campaign ad featuring Laura Murphy, whom he designated as a voice for more parental control in education. Murphy positioned herself for this role eight years ago when she pressed to give parents veto power over high school reading material -- specifically, Toni Morrison's Beloved.
The book by Morrison, the only Black woman from the U.S. to win a Nobel Prize for Literature, deals frequently with the horrific trauma faced by sexual abuse victims -- and more precisely, the role of sexual abuse and its trauma in preserving and empowering slavery.
The woman's crusade is not the first or last time someone tried to censor Beloved. The American Library Association, according to a Slate interview with Emily Knox of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, chronicled attempts around the country in 1996, 1997, 1998, 2006, 2007, 2012, 2013, 2015 and 2016.
Knox acknowledges that the novel is graphic.
"What Morrison does is ask that the reader look at the horrors of slavery without any blinders on, and that is actually what people dislike about the book," Knox told Slate.
Closer to home in York County, the Central York School Board successfully blocked the inclusion of minority writers like Kevin Noble Maillard, Hena Khan and Matthew A. Cherry from the district's curriculum for months. Protests and donors' efforts to ensure anyone who wanted the "controversial" books could have them led the Central York School Board to eventually relent.
Efforts to silence minority perspectives are all too common in a country purportedly committed to freedom of expression. That's part of the reason the James V. Brown Library's courage to foster these voices locally rather than hide them or sequester them is important. And why the staff of the James V. Brown Library has earned its "Library of the Year" status.