Breaking News
Editorials

Somebody else needs to take lead on case against mandate

3 min read

Jersey Shore Area School Board recently and unanimously approved a resolution to formally distance itself from a state mandate regarding training for teachers and staff on being more aware of cultural sensitivities and relevance.

Community members who spoke in favor of the resolution and against the mandate, which calls on educators to "identify, deepen understanding of and take steps to address bias," likened it to "indoctrination" and Critical Race Theory, as the Sun-Gazette reported in its May 25 edition.

We believe the mandate should be more closely examined. We have concerns it may well be a "one-size-fits-all" solution when a more decentralized approach would allow school districts and elected school boards to better address bias and cultural insensitivity.

However, we unfortunately must also observe that the Jersey Shore Area School District seems to be a particularly poor candidate to be at the forefront of this discussion.

Less than one week before the school board adopted the resolution, representatives of the district were in federal court. While the lawsuit alleging racial harassment and bullying was dismissed, U.S. District Judge Matthew Brann was clear that it was dismissed due to the "very high standard" of a district assuming culpability for what students did to their classmates.

Brann, to reiterate, did not doubt the veracity of the allegations. His own words, and the defense offered by the district, took the underlying allegations as fact.

"I would wonder how the parents of the harassing children are allowing their children to behave in this manner, whether they care, or whether they are condoning and encouraging it," the judge said, according to PennLive.com.

Behavior that included, according to PennLive's reporting on the lawsuit, telling their classmate they "wanted to sell him on the slave stage" and that "they wished they could travel back in time so they could own him as a slave and whip him."

Of course we sympathize with the bullied students. But we also understand and sympathize with teachers and school administrators. We respect how difficult addressing misbehavior and determining appropriate measures of discipline must be. We recognize that gathering all the facts on who did what or who said what, especially when often the bullied or harassed students may not even be sure themselves, is an arduous and frustrating task.

However, we cannot recall any resolutions passed unanimously by the board condemning this behavior as strongly as the board condemned the state's proposal. Nor can we recall community members likening the students' desire to own and whip their classmates to "Marxism," as several said about the state mandate.

We understand that concerns in the Jersey Shore Area School District about the state's plan are sincere. We understand that recommending that the leaders and constituents who harbor these sincere concerns step aside in the conversation, due to the repugnant misbehavior of some students, may seem unfair.

But -- as we suspect many of these leaders and constituents often remind the youth of Jersey Shore and the surrounding communities -- life often isn't fair.

If further examination of the cultural relevance mandate reveals more deficiencies, we hope locally elected school boards are able to persuade the state to revise and improve the measure.

And -- fair or not -- we also believe school districts that didn't need a federal judge to admonish the racist conduct of their student bodies are better positioned to lobby for any changes.

Starting at /week.