Trending
The sexual harassment scandal roiling the administration of Gov. Josh Shapiro has highlighted the increasingly controversial use of non-disclosure agreements in sexual misconduct settlements. While it is difficult, of not impossible, to say whether an NDA is unjust in any particular case, given the power imbalance between accusers and institutions -- especially governments -- they should be used sparingly, at most.
While 17 states have restricted NDAs in sexual misconduct settlements, it is not necessary for Pennsylvania to enact legislation to make a small change in favor of transparency and victims' rights: The Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission (PHRC) should amend its default settlement form to exclude, rather than include, non-disparagement and confidentiality clauses.
In March, a female employee in Mr. Shapiro's Office of Legislative Affairs alleged the office's head, long-time Shapiro aide and ally Mike Vereb, committed sexual harassment and retaliation. The accusations only came to light in September, when Mr. Vereb was allowed to resign as media caught wind of the story.
Earlier that month, the accuser had agreed to a $295,000 settlement that included a mutual non-disclosure agreement. The NDA binds both sides from discussing details of the case: The Commonwealth gets the benefit of potentially damaging details remaining secret, while the accuser is said to get the benefit of privacy.
Mr. Shapiro's handling of the situation has been perplexing, at best. The governor's office released a statement praising Mr. Vereb upon his dignified departure, and Mr. Shapiro himself has never publicly broken with him.
It's uncertain when Mr. Shapiro first became aware of the allegations against one of his top advisers. We do know that the complaint was escalated to the PHRC in June. If the office's protocols were followed, the governor would have been notified of the complaints by mid-July at the latest. Yet two more months passed, with Mr. Vereb continuing his public duties, until his September resignation.
The settlement agreement frees Mr. Shapiro from having to explain this delay.
A structural problem with NDAs in cases like this is that, in binding both sides equally, it gives the public impression that both sides' claims are equal, when in reality very few sexual misconduct claims are contrived. While institutions -- whether corporate or public -- have many means at their disposal to continue to protect themselves, and to subtly press their case, individual accusers do not. In other words, in most cases, the NDA's mantle of protection is much broader over the institution than the individual.
In negotiations, the individual accuser is also at a disadvantage -- unless he or she can afford a team of excellent lawyers -- against a behemoth. In that context, the silence ensured by the NDA can be held out as a requirement to receive the justice of a settlement payout.
The Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission offers mediation of employment related disputes in both the public and private sector, and that's ultimately where the Vereb case ended up. When parties reach a settlement, the PHRC offers a form in which to fill out the details. Curiously, both non-disparagement and non-disclosure agreements are included in the default settlement form. In other words, the accuser must negotiate them out of the agreement, instead of into it.
This places the commission's thumb on the scales in favor of NDAs, nudging all parties away from transparency. While it is often said that accusers generally desire the protections of an NDA, it's hard to know when they are presented with them as faits accomplis.
As an independent commission (whose board members are appointed by the governor), the PHRC can change its settlement forms. It should do so: NDAs should never be the default, and should only ever be added on the initiative of the person whose protection is most important -- the victim.
-- Pittsburgh Post-Gazette