What other newspapers are saying: Opening primaries won’t heal politics — but it will help
Trending
Pennsylvania's closed primary system -- one of only seven remaining among the 50 states -- contributes not just to political polarization, but to decline in the quality of governance by giving each party's ideological base too much power in selecting candidates. Nowhere is this clearer than in regions where a single party dominates the electorate, where the closed system effectively disenfranchises voters who would apply moderating pressure on candidates and elected officials.
Finally, a bill to bring Pennsylvania in line with the majority of states that have more open primaries has passed the House State Government Committee -- unfortunately on a party-line vote, with Democrats voting in favor. The proposal would allow unaffiliated, or independent, voters to vote in any party's primary. The full chamber should pass the bill quickly, and the Senate should follow suit, so its provisions can be in place as soon as possible -- ideally by next spring's primaries.
For most of American history, party leaders selected their candidates in secret, often corrupt arrangements that blocked regular voters out of the process. The primary system emerged as a democratic reform, allowing the people to select their own candidates.
Over the years, however, the process of reform continued, and most primary systems became more open. But not in Pennsylvania.
About 950,000 Pennsylvanians, or 11% of registered voters, are independent. That's not enough to radically change the electoral arithmetic, but it is enough to decrease the power of the most strident voters in each party's base. Further, freed from the obligation to register with a party to vote in primaries, many more voters will choose to be unaffiliated.
It's hard to overstate how much the current primary system has warped Pittsburgh politics in recent years. Candidates who represent the progressive wing of the Democratic Party consistently win primaries on the strength of the party's activist base, then face no or token opposition in the general election. As a result, a small cadre of the most passionate progressives have come to hold significant power.
Besides the elections themselves, in which only about one in four Democratic voters participate, elected officials feel they must always appease this ideological base or risk losing to a progressive primary challenger. As a result, local governance has lurched to the left far more than the full electorate has.
This process hasn't just occurred in high-profile races, but also in small municipal elections, which have become increasingly ideological -- and which are producing the next round of regional leaders.
The primary system is also, in part, responsible the success of far-right "MAGA" candidates in red regions, including all over Pennsylvania. A sign that opening primaries to unaffiliated voters isn't a cure-all: Obnoxious firebrand Lauren Boebert won multiple GOP primaries in Colorado, which has the system Pennsylvania is considering.
Ultimately, the only way to restore a politics of civility and pragmatism and compromise is through voters valuing those qualities -- and then actually voting in both the primary and general elections. But opening primaries to independents is an important structural reform that will make it easier to get there.
-- Pittsburgh Post-Gazette