Breaking News
Editorials

What other newspapers are saying: Manchin and the ‘middle’

4 min read

Sen. Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., said this week he'd consider a third-party presidential run on a centrist ticket representing "the radical middle" of U.S. politics, if it will save the nation. It's worth pondering just what he means by that, beyond the self-acknowledged oxymoron of the term "radical middle."

Manchin announced that he wouldn't seek reelection to his U.S. Senate seat two days after voters across the country rewarded moderate Democrats and rejected extremist Republicans politicians and policies (as well as some far-left Dems) in the off-year general election. As was said before, that seems like odd timing. He said he would embark on a tour of the country to see if there is an interest in building a nondescript centrist platform.

In a way, Manchin has been here before.

When he was the linchpin Democratic vote for Biden administration policies in a 50-50 Senate, with Vice President Kamala Harris holding the Dems' tie-breaker, Manchin occasionally frustrated his caucus with his insistence on bipartisan dealmaking. That frustration was elevated when it came to high-stakes legislation, such as election security and voting rights, because Republicans refused to even come to the table, and Manchin should've known they wouldn't. Some questioned if Manchin even knew what he really wanted in such situations, or was simply bargaining for the sake of it.

His latest statements on finding the middle raise similar questions. Does Manchin know what "the middle" is or why he's looking for it? Would he recognize it if he found it?

Political pundit and 2004 Bush-Cheney presidential campaign chief Matthew Dowd touched on that during a segment on liberal-leaning cable news network MSNBC this week.

"I don't know what he's actually talking about (when Manchin mentions) the center of the country," Dowd said. "He might be unfamiliar with what the center of the country is, but, on almost every major issue, Joe Biden is in the center, the exact center, of the country. He's in the center of the country on Roe v. Wade. He's in the center of the country on commonsense gun reform. He's in the center of the country on raising the minimum wage and higher taxes on the wealthy. He's in the center of the country on what to do in international politics. He's in the center of the country on protecting our democracy."

Dowd went on to say that Manchin might not be as moderate as he thinks, noting that most Americans favor action on climate change and a federal law granting access to abortion after the Supreme Court overturned Roe. Manchin has stymied progress on these issues during his time in the Senate. (It's worth noting that Dowd said Manchin has roadblocked gun control laws, which is only partly true. Manchin and former Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Pa., tried, unsuccessfully, to pass a bill for expanded background checks on firearm purchases after the 2012 massacre at Sandy Hook Elementary, in Connecticut.

However, Manchin did oppose two gun control bills passed by the U.S. House in 2021.)

This assessment obviously doesn't gel with Manchin's statements that Joe Biden has moved too far left -- which seem to rest solely on the president's initiatives for alternative and renewable energy sources -- but it certainly provides a counterpoint to the accuracy of such a claim, as well as raising some important questions about Manchin's quest.

Manchin considering a third-party bid for president also presents something of a logical puzzle.

Donald Trump is the Republican front-runner, and Manchin believes, with good reason, that Trump will wreck the country if allowed back in the Oval Office. Most believe that, if Manchin were to run as a third-party candidate, he certainly stands no chance of winning and would take votes from Biden (in fairness, some also theorize that he'd take votes from Trump). Manchin said he doesn't want to play "spoiler," but that's exactly what he would be doing.

Manchin's decision not to seek reelection has all but guaranteed a flip in that Senate seat, making it more difficult for Democrats to retain control of the chamber, and now he might make it easier for someone he believes will destroy the nation to attain the presidency while also claiming he has "a burning desire to save this nation, whatever it takes."

Talk about mental whiplash. How can anyone find the center when they're all over the map like that?

-- Charleston Gazette-Mail

Starting at /week.