Breaking News
Other Commentaries

Open primaries keep politicians on toes

6 min read

It's not often these days that a so-called partisan political leader publicly ushers praise on a representative from the opposing party. On September 29, Pennsylvania's House of Representatives passed House Bill 280 by a bipartisan vote of 115-88. The bill would allow unaffiliated voters to participate in one major-party primary of their choice. HB 280 will likely linger in Harrisburg until such time after January when Democrats officially gain a "trifecta" control of the governor's office and both the state House and Senate.

Pennsylvania has operated under closed primary elections for nearly 90 years since the 1937 Election Code. And we remain one of the last few states that prevent politically unaffiliated voters -- registered independents, Green Party members, etc. -- from taking part in primary elections. One of the Republican votes in favor of HB 280 in September came from State Rep. Jamie Flick (R-83).

It is difficult to dislike Flick, and even more difficult to challenge his principled voting record. As chair of the

Democratic Party in Pennsylvania's largest county by area, and as the person theoretically responsible for fielding an opposing candidate against him, I'll readily admit that I still have yet to figure out Jamie Flick. He is a political anomaly not only in Lycoming County but in the Pennsylvania House of Representatives.

Criticizing someone who effectively does their job to the relative satisfaction of the so-called opposition is no small accomplishment. By contrast, I have often fantasized about State Rep. Joe Hamm (R-Lycoming) being forced to spend serious money to retain his seat, given his record of doing the bare minimum and casting occasionally bizarre votes -- such as being the lone "no" vote against a near-unanimous bill prioritizing accessible playgrounds for children with disabilities.

After the HB 280 vote, I reached out to Rep. Flick to personally thank him for his leadership and vote on open primaries. I knew all too well that I would probably be one of the few to do so. Flick was candid: "You wouldn't believe the hate mail I'm getting," he said, adding: "Well, maybe you would." And he was right.

People are entitled to their own views on open primaries. And I don't seek to necessarily persuade every voter to support this change, in part because I believe some version of reform is likely to occur regardless. But what I am saying is that opening Pennsylvania's primaries would jolt the state's political system. It would keep Democrats on their toes and should leave Republican operatives salivating at the endless possibilities.

Many Republicans oppose open primaries because it's generally accepted the change would cost them electoral victories. Party leaders also argue it would weaken their control over the candidate nomination process. To be fair, that control was weakened years ago with the effective loss in value of any party's endorsement.

For example, the Lycoming County Republican Committee under its previous leadership refused to endorse Rep. Flick in 2022 over their hand-picked primary challenger, and they again refused to endorse Flick's 2024 re-election bid despite Flick's easy win in the November election. This goes to show that political parties, not open primaries, are the actual problem.

Open or semi-open primaries democratize the process by giving more power to voters, rather than to the political party leaders. So as one party leader, I ask my Republican counterparts: Who cares? A party confident in its policies and public standing should have little to fear from voters.

Meanwhile, unaffiliated Pennsylvania voters now make up more than 13 percent of the state's electorate -- roughly 1.2 to 1.5 million people--and their numbers have grown in recent years while both major parties have seen fluctuations and relative losses in voter registration.

An open primary system could be a genuine win-win for several reasons. It is entirely conceivable that broader primary participation could help produce a "normalized" Republican Party more competitive with the wider electorate as something closer to a pre-Trump version of the party in its electoral appeal. According to Pew Research Center, the overall electoral balance among independents has trended roughly even or modestly Democratic in most recent cycles.

However, outcomes still heavily depend on candidate quality, turnout, media coverage, and local conditions, which would all still remain largely controllable in an open primary system. True independent swing voters are a relatively small group, while most "independents" are leaners who vote much like partisans. To translate: The country typically votes in "mood swings."

In recent election cycles, a number of right-win GOP primary winners have gone on to high-profile general election defeats. Those reasons why can be up for debate. But what's not debatable is that Donald Trump's political standing is toxic for candidates of the Trump Republican Party.

The November 2026 election can reasonably be viewed as a rejection of the more right-win MAGA faction of Trump's GOP that has struggled to expand beyond its core base. To be clear, both the Republican and Democratic parties have their own separate diverting factions within their ranks.

In Pennsylvania, look no further than state Treasurer Stacy Garrity's crushing defeat in the 2026 governor's race against incumbent Gov. Josh Shapiro. But the 2022 gubernatorial contest offers an even clearer illustration.

Shapiro's campaign spent nearly $1 million on television ads to manipulate the Republican primary election that effectively boosted State Sen. Doug Mastriano -- a loyal Trump sycophant, hard right-wing candidate, and nominee to be U.S. ambassador to Slovakia--in a crowded field of more than ten other contenders. Shapiro's campaign team was well aware that Mastriano would struggle deeply to appeal to a broader electorate in the general election.

To summarize: Diehard Democrats should not automatically assume that open primaries would guarantee a win for Democratic candidates. In practice, the change could level the playing field by giving more electable, non-Trump Republican candidates a better chance to win both the primary and the general election.

State Rep. Jamie Flick himself is a useful example of how a common-sense Republican might perform better, for example, in a state senate primary election against a more right-wing candidate, such as Joe Hamm, when given a fairer shot with a broader primary electorate. Few things say "America First" than elections controlled by the people, not politicians.

Chris Benson, an author, media professional, political consultant, and registered lobbyist under the Pennsylvania Department of State, is chair of the Lycoming County Democratic Committee.

Starting at /week.