×

Legislators likely to take state’s mask mandate to court

HARRISBURG (AP) — The mask mandate for schools that went into effect Tuesday is almost certainly headed to the courts.

“We’ve seen litigation now for months,” said Eric Feldman, a professor of medical ethics and health policy at the University of Pennsylvania, according to the Erie Times-News Tuesday. “Most of it has failed, not just in progressive states with judges appointed by liberals, but also with judges appointed by former President Trump. … So will we see litigation? Yes. Will it succeed? I doubt it.”

An attorney participating in a lawsuit to overturn the mandate disagrees.

“They’ve used powers that would rightfully be those of local schools. It’s up to school boards to decide,” Thomas King III of the law firm Dillon McCandless King Coulter and Graham said, KDKA-TV reported on Monday.

Feldman cautioned that schools also could be sued if they failed to implement masking, the Erie Times-News reported.

The Republican leader of the state Senate and a group of parents filed the lawsuit Friday seeking to overturn the Wolf administration’s new mask mandate for Pennsylvania schools.

The governor’s spokesperson dismissed what she called the GOP’s “effort at undermining public heath.”

The suit, filed in Commonwealth Court, asserts that Acting Health Secretary Alison Beam failed to comply with state law when she ordered masks to be worn in all Pennsylvania public and private schools, as well as child care facilities.

The masking order isn’t valid because it didn’t go through the state’s regulatory review process, the lawsuit said. It also accused the Wolf administration of trying to circumvent newly approved constitutional amendments limiting a governor’s emergency powers.

“The Secretary of Health’s order subjects healthy, non-infected teachers, children, students, staff, and visitors … to the wearing of face coverings,” the suit said. The plaintiffs, it said, are “not patients, they are heathy, non-infected children.”

The plaintiffs include Senate President Pro Tempore Jake Corman, R-Bellefonte; Rep. Jesse Topper, R-Bedford; two private Christian schools; and parents in three public school districts — Wyomissing Area in Berks County, and Butler Area and Slippery Rock Area, both in Butler County.

The parents said in affidavits that they intend to send their children to school without masks, claiming Beam’s order is illegal.

The lawsuit seeks an injunction against the masking order. The court scheduled a hearing for Sept. 16.

Lyndsay Kensinger, spokesperson for Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf, said Friday that the health secretary’s authority is “clearly outlined in existing law.”

“We need Republicans to stop spending their time undermining public heath and instead encourage people to get vaccinated,” she added.

The health secretary’s order, which took effect on Tuesday, will require students, teachers and staff to wear face coverings when inside, regardless of vaccination status.

Wolf said this week that a universal, statewide order was necessary after most of Pennsylvania’s 500 school districts did not impose their own mask mandates.

State health officials said more than 5,000 students have tested positive for the coronavirus since the start of the academic year.

Starting at $2.99/week.

Subscribe Today